In the report [14, 32], validators write that Jeanne has mentioned the servant Marthe Fousson, and they cite the census of 1911 in which she is counted together with the Calment family. The only mention of a servant with the name Marthe that I found in the biographies of Calment was the following: Did you go to school with your friends, or did you go alone? "My father or the maid accompanied me…" What was the maid called? "Marthe, Marthe Touchon." [4, 5] In the last years of Calment's life when these validation talks took place, she had difficulty with speaking precisely [5]. On the basis of almost identical-sounding surnames and the coincidence of the name, and taking into account that there was nobody named Marthe living with Jeanne or nearby when she was a child according to censuses, and the only servant found in the census of 1886 was called Marguerite Minaud (who was a relative of Jeanne born without a father), I conclude that Marthe Touchon is the same maid as Marthe Fousson from the validation report. But, according to the archives of the commune of Fontvieille, she was born on 8th of March 1885 and thus was 10 years younger than Jeanne, so she couldn't accompany Jeanne to school. However, she could well accompany her daughter Yvonne 0186名も無き挑戦者@Record2019/01/08(火) 00:18:37.77ID:ykHGn4pg>>149 >>185 やっぱりカルマン婆さんは残念嘘松インチキ記録だったか…… 完璧に今までの絶対視タブー視され続け聖域だった闇に光が差した様だな 0187名も無き挑戦者@Record2019/01/08(火) 00:27:55.01ID:SlNJmaMH 歳取れば顔つき変わるのは当たり前だろ 田島ナビさんだって60代の身分証明書とは全然違う身体的特著だとおもうが 0188名も無き挑戦者@Record2019/01/08(火) 00:46:28.33ID:1uxwJdcZ>>184 68歳が2ちゃんとか世も末だな 0189名も無き挑戦者@Record2019/01/08(火) 00:54:21.29ID:4ffPxGug 人間は115歳を超えた位が限界なんだな 0190名も無き挑戦者@Record2019/01/08(火) 00:54:29.33ID:0k7IlNGt もしカルマンさんが娘だったとして、夫は娘と夫婦として生活を送ったのか? 途中から親子が入れ替わったら、家族だけじゃなく周りも怪しむだろう?証言が外野からも無いのはおかしいような気がするけどなぁ。 0191名も無き挑戦者@Record2019/01/08(火) 00:57:59.80ID:NigHULQc>>187 顔つきが変わったなんて言ってないんだよな〜。 むしろその逆で、 若い頃のイボンヌの写真と122歳と称する女性の写真で目の間隔や鼻の形など年齢によって変化しない顔の要素一致したと言ってる。 そしてなぜか若い頃のジャンヌの写真と122歳と称する女性の写真ではそれらが一致していない、とね。 0192名も無き挑戦者@Record2019/01/08(火) 00:58:21.42ID:JTOIQIzO 大還暦到達者がいないというのも寂しいな 0193名も無き挑戦者@Record2019/01/08(火) 00:59:39.25ID:1uxwJdcZ さっさとDNA検査して欲しいな 0194名も無き挑戦者@Record2019/01/08(火) 01:17:04.51ID:XXwsQjuL>>191 言ってるじゃねーかw